Are Stradivarius Violin Copies Good?

Stradivarius violins are the holy grail of violins, but true Strads are some of the costliest instruments in the world. In fact, they can be so expensive that they have become more of a collector’s item than something that most musicians can use on a daily basis. This has created a market for copies of Stradivarius violins that are much more affordable and accessible. However, this does raise the question – are Stradivarius violin copies good? That depends on a lot of factors, and we will expand on each one of them to come to a facts-driven conclusion.

Table of Contents

A Little Background on Stradivarius Violins First

The Stradivari family was a family of instrument makers who were most prolific during the 17th and 18th centuries. Antonio Stradivari was the most renowned member of this family. It is usually violins made by him that are referred to as Stradivarius violins based on his name in Latin. At the time, this family, along with Antonio, was one of the many families from Italy who made all types of string instruments like violins, cellos, violas, etc. Initially, Stradivarius instruments weren’t seen as any more special than the violins made by the other families from the same general area in Italy. However, as the decades and centuries went by, pro violinists began to prefer Strads over other violins. Slowly, these instruments started to gain an almost mystical reputation. This hype just kept growing to the point that decent-quality Stradivarius violins can go for millions of dollars in auctions these days.

Is There Anything Quantifiably Special About Stradivarius Violins?

This is a very controversial topic as people tend to make strong arguments both for and against the specialness of Stradivarius violins. Plenty of research has taken place to scientifically prove why Strads are so special. However, to date, nothing that can be measured has been found that can prove that Stradivarius violins are indeed special.

It isn’t the end of the argument, though. Music isn’t something that can be broken down into mathematical formulas, or we would be living in an era of AI-generated music. There is something about music that cannot be analyzed and broken down, and perhaps the same applies to these violins. Since some of the most renowned violinists swear that these violins have an almost magical quality to them, it should at least be partially true. To put it simply. It is all subjective, and there are plenty of violinists out there who can produce mesmerizing sounds out of a bog-standard violin that can be picked up for a reasonable price from a regular violin shop.

How Affordable Are Stradivarius Violin Copies?

Since the original Stradivarius violins go for ridiculous amounts of money, the sky is the limit for the price of their copies. It depends on how good the copy is. There is also no standard way of classifying a violin as a Stradivarius copy. As such, anyone can simply put a label on a violin and call it a Strad copy. The price of these copies can range from as low as $50 to as high as $50,000 and sometimes even more.

The exact price will depend on a lot of factors such as the maker of the copy, past reputation, marketing, hand-made or mass-manufactured, and the materials used. Like all stringed instruments, all violins, even those made by the same person, don’t sound exactly the same. So, an expensive copy won’t necessarily sound better than a cheaper copy. However, as long as you get it from a reputed source and you play the violin before buying, you should get at least a reasonably good instrument at a very reasonable price.

Cheap Stradivarius Knockoffs Or Great Instruments?

As mentioned before, there is no standardized system of classifying a violin as a Stradivarius copy. It basically boils down to a marketing choice on the seller’s part. You are as likely to end up with a cheap knock as you are to end up with a great violin. Some people think that spending more money will increase their chances of getting a great instrument. This, again, is not true. The surest way of ensuring that you get a great violin is by actually playing the violin. This will not only help you get a first-hand experience of how the violin sounds and feels, but it will also help you gauge if you can connect with the instrument on a personal level which is more important than anything else.

Why Are Stradivarius Violin Copies Desirable?

Since no one really knows why the real Stradivarius violins sound the way they do, there is no specific reason why there is such a huge demand for its copies either. The most obvious reason is the value associated with the Stradivarius name. It is a common fallacy in the world of musical instruments where the ability to play great music and expensive instruments with renowned branding are seen as interdependent on each other.

A more rational explanation is that the Stradivarius design is something that has stood the test of time for centuries now. With a good Stradivarius copy, you are assured of an instrument that will have a high chance of checking all the right boxes both in terms of the sound and the feel.

The Harsh Truth About Stradivarius Violin Copies

We already alluded to this. The plain truth that many aspiring musicians do not want to admit is that a better instrument will not make them better at playing the instrument. There is no substitute for hard work and the sheer number of hours that you can put into learning to play the instrument. So, if your sole motivation behind purchasing a Stradivarius copy is to become a better musician instantaneously, then you are in for some disappointment.

The only positive effect could be in the form of added motivation. If you feel that you will be more inclined to pick up a Stradivarius copy and actually play when compared to a regular violin, then investing in one of these copies makes a lot more sense.

Stradivarius Violin Copies Vs Regular Violins?

There is no obvious difference between the two from a purely musical standpoint. As long as the violin is manufactured properly and there are no defects, it should sound and play well enough. However, it is important to remember that an instrument is just a tool, and it is the musician that makes most of the difference. So, choose the violin you connect with the most instead of letting any branding influence your final decision.

Pros Of Stradivarius Violin Copies

A design that has stood the test of time
Can act as a motivation to actually pick the instrument up and practice
Can be seen as cool in some circles
Are much more affordable than real Stradivarius violins

Cons Of Stradivarius Violin Copies

Huge variance in quality
Can often end up as nothing more than a cheap knockoff
No guarantee of getting an instrument that you will connect with on a personal level